Skip to content
Life Stories AE

Women Service Members Push Back to Defense Secretary's Comments on Military Requirements

Female US Army service members discuss military requirements
Female US Army veterans state that standards for military roles were consistently the same, irrespective of gender.

Female service members who served in the US military are pushing back against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's statement that requirements for combat roles will "return to the highest male standard," saying the standards have historically been the equal for men and women.

"None of us have ever requested preferential treatment," a former US Navy service member, who served for five years, told reporters.

Speaking hundreds of generals on Tuesday, Hegseth reiterated his views that the military had lowered requirements to include women and put troops at danger. His recent orders would bring them back to a higher level, he stated.

"If it means zero females qualify for combat jobs, then that's acceptable," he remarked.

He maintained that women would not be excluded from the armed forces completely.

Some female veterans were outraged.

"I am fed up of Pete Hegseth lying about female service members and standards," ex-military aviator Amy McGarth declared in a social media post.

"There has always been a single benchmark for such positions," she added. "There was never a man's standard or a female criterion for operating an aircraft."

The Navy veteran, too, said that gender and age were not part of evaluations given for military positions.

Military requirements are established variably based on the division a person is serving in, whether they are in special operations, infantry, armour or rescue teams, she noted. However, all personnel in those roles have to pass the same test.

"These requirements have always been gender neutral, and they have historically been established at a rigorous level," she remarked. "Of course, some females are going to make those, but not all men fail as well."

This is not the identical for the annual physical tests given to all personnel, which include standard drills like upper-body exercises. In those cases, the requirements and results differ according to years and sex, and the tests differ by unit.

The veteran said it remains unclear if Hegseth will actually implement major reforms to how service members are assessed.

In his address, Hegseth said: "Any place that tried-and-true fitness requirements were altered, particularly since 2015, when combat arms benchmarks were changed to allow women could meet criteria, must be restored to their original standard."

He seemed to allude to a directive in 2015 by the former Pentagon chief Ash Carter that every armed forces position be available for female personnel and that any person, regardless of gender, who fulfills the criteria should be able to serve.

"When it comes to every position that requires physical power to perform in battle, those physical standards must be rigorous and unbiased," Hegseth said. "Should females can succeed, excellent. Otherwise, that's the reality."

In general, Hegseth explained he was revising requirements throughout the military to "fix years of decline" and that the armed forces have "advanced an excess of officers for the wrong reasons," like ethnicity, sex and "notable initial achievements."

Lawmaker Tammy Duckworth, an former service member who was severely injured while on duty as a military aviator in the Middle East, commented to media outlets after the address: "For a guy who's unfit for his own job, it's pretty discriminatory to talk about females who are qualified to perform their duties."

She noted that his remarks could harm recruitment.

Women in the US military were first allowed to fly combat aircraft in the Navy and Air Force in 1993, though they were barred from ground combat. This shifted in recent years when the Combat Exclusion Policy was lifted and by 2016 military positions were available for all.

Because of how not long ago females were included in all ranks, numerous are now still in the midst of their professional paths, the veteran said.

"It takes time to observe females achieve high ranks, and we haven't had a chance to witness it," she remarked.

Currently active and veteran women in the military are concerned that Hegseth is building a armed forces environment where female personnel will be marginalized and unable to advance, she said.

"Command establishes the atmosphere," she added.

Some female soldiers opposed Hegseth's statements.

GOP lawmaker Sheri Biggs, who was enlisted as a senior officer in the reserve unit, said in a statement that she backed the defence secretary's initiatives to eliminate "progressive" directives from the military.

"Reverting to requirements that prioritize excellence and accountability puts America's security and our servicemembers where they belong — foremost," Biggs said.

A further South Carolina Republican, Representative Nancy Mace, who graduated from The Citadel academy, posted on social media in favor of Hegseth.

"Adversaries are not intimidated by inclusion metrics. They fear American firepower," she wrote.

The writer

Heather Ramos

A passionate storyteller from Dubai, Zara shares real-life experiences to inspire and connect communities through authentic narratives.

Life Stories AE

Type to search articles.